Hierarchies of Fat Loss

by Lisa on March 20, 2010 · 32 comments

I came across this article by Alwyn Crosgrove who is a respected coach and speaker in the fitness industry. He has written many books including big titles like “New Rules of Lifting” and “Body Sculpting Bible for Women.” In short, he seems to know his stuff and I always find his information very interesting.

So, have you ever heard the question “I want to lose fat, but not muscle. How do I do that”

One of the first points he mentions regarding fat loss is this…

I think whenever we try to pursue two goals at once we tend to compromise results. This is usually because we have a limited resource: time. If our goal is to generate fat loss, then using a periodized training approach with a specific fat loss phase (e.g. four weeks, eight weeks, etc.) where we focus exclusively on fat loss will always yield better results in the long term than trying to juggle two goals at once.

In short, stick to one goal. Have that be fat loss. Don’t try to gain muscle and lose fat at the same time. It just doesn’t work that way. Pick one goal and stick to it for best results.

That being said, here’s a summary of the Hierachry of Fat Loss.

  1. Correct Nutrition
    You simply can’t workout enough to compensate for a bad diet.
    Crosgrove says you must create a calorie deficit first through nutrition by getting enough protein and essential fats.
  2. Activities that burn calories, maintain/promote muscle mass, and elevate metabolism
    The bulk of our calories burned is largely dependent on our resting metabolic rate. So, adding activities that will elevate  the metablic rate while promoting or maintain muscle mass is extremely important is the biggest part in your fat loss plan. This means doing resistance exercise.
  3. Activities that burn calories and elevate metabolism
    These are activities that burn calories and increase your EPOC or Exercise Post Oxygen Consumption, which basically means, exercise that burns up calories even after you are done exercising. Think HIIT.

Activities that burn calories but don’t necessarily maintain muscle or elevate metabolism
This is your icing on the cake as Crosgrove refers it. This is activity that burns a little calorie but doesn’t increase your metabolism. Think light cardio, etc.

Let’s do a little recap…


The greater the intensity of your exercise, the greater your EPOC will be.

  1. The single most important type of exercise you can do while trying to lose fat is RESISTANCE EXERCISE. Ladies, don’t be afraid of lifting weights and becoming bulky. It simply doesn’t work that way for us ladies. According to a study, individuals were found to burn calories up to 38 hours after their resistance workout! CRAZY! So, lift ladies.
  2. High Intensity Anaerobic Interval Training is the next tool in your arensal of fat loss weapons. In a study of people participating in endurance activity and others participated in HIIT, it was found that calorie for calorie the individuals who did HIIT burned NINE TIMES MORE FAT than their endurance counterparts. That’s not to say steady state is useless, because it isn’t. It has its place. But so does HIIT, so do it from time to time.
  3. High Intensity Aerobic Interval Training is the next most important took in your fat loss plan. This is essentially a lower intesity aerobic interval workout.
  4. Steady State High Intensity
    This is just simple steady state hard cardio. This is just to burn calories, not to increase your EPOC. Basically, the calories you burn doing this will eventually add up.
  5. Steady State Low Intensity
    Lastly, this is just activity. Taking your dog for a walk, shopping at the mall, etc.

I’m sure the next question you have is…”Well, that’s great Lisa, but how the heck do I fit all that into my busy schedule?”

Here’s what Crosgrove suggests..

If you have 3 hours per week, use only #1 above: metabolic resistance training

This can be three, one-hour training sessions, or four 45-minute training sessions. It doesn’t seem to matter.

If you have 3-5 hours…

use #1 and # 2: weight training plus high intensity interval work

At this point, any additional work is usually in the form of high intensity interval training. I’m looking to burn up more calories and continue to elevate EPOC.

If you have 5-6 hours…

Aerobic intervals wins out at this point because it’s still higher intensity overall than steady state work so it burns more calories. There appears to be a fat oxidation benefit and will still be easier to recover from than additional anaerobic work.

If you have 6-8 hours…

Add # 4. If you’re not losing a lot of fat with six hours of training already, then I’d be taking a very close look at your diet.

That’s it ladies. Hope you found it to be a little bit interesting… I know I did. I have followed principles similiar to this over the past 3 years and have seen great results. I know that nutrition and fat loss and muscle gain can be so confusing, so hopefully this helps shed light to the situation.

In the end though, I think finding something you like and can STICK WITH is really the biggest key in fat loss and feeling good. If you absolutely hate lifting, then, well, you won’t ever do it and you won’t  lose fat that way.

To get more in-depth information on this article, go here. Plus, he has tons of other great articles on his site as well.

Source: http://alwyncosgrove.com/2010/01/hierarchy-of-fat-loss/

{ 28 comments… read them below or add one }

Heather (Where's the Beach) March 20, 2010 at 6:56 pm

Thanks for the info! I actually have the book New Rules of Lifting. I wish more women would recognize the benefits rather than fearing being bulky.

Reply

Kelly March 20, 2010 at 7:02 pm

Thanks for this! Since I can’t run right now I’m trying to find ways to make sure I don’t gain any more weight than I already have since I stopped running! I think this will help, have a great night!

Reply

Katie @ Health for the Whole Self March 20, 2010 at 7:14 pm

Thanks for sharing this! I found all of it extremely interesting. I love that you’re helping to dispel that silly myth that women are going to “bulk up” if they do heavy strength training.

Reply

Whole Body Love March 20, 2010 at 9:11 pm

I am just learning about HIIT because I am starting BFL. I did read THe New Rules Of Lifting For Women though and I found it pretty informative

Reply

Amy @ Second City Randomness March 20, 2010 at 9:15 pm

I like the way you broke this down- and point out that narrowing it down to one goal at a time is key! I feel like people who try to do more than one thing end up overwhelming themselves and give up…

Reply

MelissaNibbles March 20, 2010 at 9:59 pm

Great article. I think one goal at a time is best as well. Intervals totally changed my body once I did BFL and I never looked back!

Reply

Andrea@WellnessNotes March 20, 2010 at 10:39 pm

Thank you so much for a very informative post! I’ve been wanting to read Alwyn Crosgrove’s books for a while now…

Reply

Jenn N. March 21, 2010 at 1:02 am

I really like Alwyn Crosgrove. I read Afterburn and did a lot of those workouts. I also read another one but I can’t remember the name…warpspeed maybe??. All of his stuff is very similar…regardless I like his approach!

Reply

Vee March 21, 2010 at 3:17 am

Great post! I want to see more women in the lifting area of my gym. Not only are all of those above great for fat loss, they are also great for having stronger bones as weight bearing exercises (as well as and high impact ones), will increase bone density.
BTW I saw your previous article about jumping lunges. Yay! I love those. They always kick my butt (literally ;-) ).

Reply

Jenny March 21, 2010 at 10:26 am

What an interesting article- definetly some good info to think about!

Reply

Danielle March 21, 2010 at 10:26 am

Interesting article, thanks for sharing! If ANYone is afraid of lifting weights in fear that they’ll become bulky…just look at pics of me lol.

Reply

homecookedem March 21, 2010 at 12:37 pm

Lots of good info here, thanks!! I like the part that says we shouldn’t try to reach 2 goals at once – focus on fat loss first then worry about gaining muscle.

Reply

Morgan @ Healthy Happy Place March 21, 2010 at 1:54 pm

I’m learning all of this in my personal training textbook. it’s so interesting!

Reply

Denise March 21, 2010 at 2:08 pm

That article is so true. If there are any older ladies out there don’t be afraid to lift weights. You will feel great when you are done and you will NOT get bulky. I did BFL and it incorporates weight training, I fell in love with it then. I like the part about focusing on 1 goal at a time, We usually want it all so we try to do it all and we accomplish nothing.

Thanks Lisa – that was a great post.

Reply

Kat March 21, 2010 at 7:51 pm

Great post! This stuff is really fascinating. I try really hard to find a balanced exercise regime that includes muscle building and cardio.

Reply

janetha March 21, 2010 at 8:19 pm

ive pondered buying the new rules of lifting book.. how is it?

this post rocks. and from my own experience, i aimed to lose fat and in turn gained muscle. it just happens. lifting weights and eating right will just result in both. i lost 9% body fat and i think it equated to a 12 lb fat loss and a 3 lb muscle gain.

i am going to link back to this post in my next one. thanks for putting it together!

Reply

Katie March 21, 2010 at 10:56 pm

LOVE this post so, so, so much. Personally, I think I add the “gain muscle” goal on top of the “lose fat” goal simply because a.) I am an overachiever, and b.) I am not overweight so in my silly mind I think that I am not “allowed” to just want to lower my PBF.
Wow.
I’ve never thought about it that way before. I don’t allow myself that single goal because losing 6% body fat seems “wrong” when there are people who are 20% away from being even remotely healthy. But I’m allowed to have that goal and that goal alone, and I’ll probably get both lower % and more muscle mass by just focusing on the one.
I’m gonna link this post. you rock!

Reply

Kelly March 22, 2010 at 10:20 am

AWESOME!! For me it sais to follow #4…which is typically what I do…yay!

Reply

kbwood March 22, 2010 at 11:17 am

such great info!! love reading about this stuff.

Reply

Sweet Cheeks March 22, 2010 at 12:44 pm

Wow, that is very interesting! Thanks for the info! Good thing I love strength training, huh?!

Reply

lowandbhold March 22, 2010 at 1:39 pm

That’s really interesting! I need to incorporate mor HIIT into my workouts for sure.

Reply

Nutritious Foodie March 22, 2010 at 2:03 pm

This was very informative. Thanks!

Reply

Therese March 22, 2010 at 2:22 pm

This is such perfect timing! I was starting to question if my high intensity workouts were going to be too much, cause a negative reaction from my body, etc. but I really think it will be the best thing for me to lean out!

Besides…I can’t stand boring, one pace at a time, type cardio! I need some excitement in my life ;)

Reply

Kelly March 22, 2010 at 5:20 pm

I definitely respect this author and i read his New Rules of Lifting for Women. Truthfully though, I did get a bit bulky- not bodybuilder but bulky, and I lost no weight at all…so
I decided to go back to my previous cardio with less intense strength training at least until the wedding and then after that I can have some fun with muscle building.
I also found strength training was making me more hungry- and even if I was burning more calories it wasn’t evening out

Reply

lisaou11 March 22, 2010 at 8:37 pm

I think you have to find something that you like and tha tmakes you feel good. I definitely think you should try lifting again in the future, but really–doing what you like will get you the best results in the end because you will actually do it! And everyone’s different–cardio makes me STARVING! :)

Reply

april March 22, 2010 at 7:44 pm

I love it! HIIT and resistance training = the best!!

Reply

Sonia @ Master of Her Romaine March 22, 2010 at 9:13 pm

yes! I totally love this post! Thank you :) I’m about to link this back to my blog…

Reply

Kerry March 23, 2010 at 3:02 am

Execellent post!! Thankyou SO much! :) xxx

Reply

Leave a Comment

CommentLuv badge

{ 4 trackbacks }

Previous post:

Next post: